No sides. Just data.

We compare what the media report with what the data say

World · International

Helen Haines’s second leg amputated but she is stable and ‘a fighter’, husband says – as it happened

Outlet: The Guardian · Martin Farrer · Published 20/10/2026 19:46 UTC

Only The Guardian reports this: no contrast yet

None of the other outlets we follow has reported this story, so there are no versions to compare. If others publish it or data appear that test it, it will move to the comparison.

Independent MP was struck by a car on Monday and her alleged attacker appeared in court on Wednesday ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see

Read on the original outlet ↗

Changes detected 19

This is live coverage; the outlet updates the headline and excerpt as it goes. We keep every version, but these changes are not corrections.

  1. Headline · detected on 21/10/2026 07:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live coverage: Helen Haines’s second leg amputated but she is stable and ‘a fighter’, husband says – as it happened

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live coverage: Helen Haines’s second leg amputated but she is stable and ‘a fighter’, husband says» c6875ca3174b

    After: «Helen Haines’s second leg amputated but she is stable and ‘a fighter’, husband says – as it happened» 931e766bb582

  2. Excerpt · detected on 21/10/2026 06:37 UTC

    Independent MP was attacked struck by a car on Monday and her alleged attacker appeared in court on Wednesday ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see their p

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Independent MP was attacked on Monday and her alleged attacker appeared in court on Wednesday ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see their p» bb9d213af204

    After: «Independent MP was struck by a car on Monday and her alleged attacker appeared in court on Wednesday ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see » ecee2d3ba52e

  3. Headline · detected on 21/10/2026 06:37 UTC

    Helen Haines live coverage: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences Helen Haines’s second leg amputated but she is stable and ‘a fighter’, husband says

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live coverage: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences» e31c4bb6d7fd

    After: «Helen Haines live coverage: Helen Haines’s second leg amputated but she is stable and ‘a fighter’, husband says» c6875ca3174b

  4. Excerpt · detected on 21/10/2026 06:07 UTC

    Independent MP’s condition remains critical MP was attacked on Monday and her alleged attacker appeared in court on Wednesday after surgery to save her remaining leg ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see thei their p

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Independent MP’s condition remains critical on Wednesday after surgery to save her remaining leg ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see thei» 326d591a0174

    After: «Independent MP was attacked on Monday and her alleged attacker appeared in court on Wednesday ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see their p» bb9d213af204

  5. Headline · detected on 21/10/2026 06:07 UTC

    Police Helen Haines live coverage: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences – as it happened

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences – as it happened» b360b10ebf35

    After: «Helen Haines live coverage: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences» e31c4bb6d7fd

  6. Headline · detected on 21/10/2026 04:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: police Police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences; lawyer says he has rare neurological condition offences – as it happened

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences; lawyer says he has rare neurological condition» 0ab5fb5053b5

    After: «Police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences – as it happened» b360b10ebf35

  7. Headline · detected on 21/10/2026 02:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offence; offences; lawyer says he has rare neurological condition

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offence; lawyer says he has rare neurological condition» 58ecd40c0ba8

    After: «Helen Haines live updates: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offences; lawyer says he has rare neurological condition» 0ab5fb5053b5

  8. Headline · detected on 21/10/2026 01:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: police charge accused Brendan Nugent doesn’t apply for bail in first court appearance since alleged attack with additional offence; lawyer says he has rare neurological condition

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: Brendan Nugent doesn’t apply for bail in first court appearance since alleged attack» f18a224bf282

    After: «Helen Haines live updates: police charge accused Brendan Nugent with additional offence; lawyer says he has rare neurological condition» 58ecd40c0ba8

  9. Excerpt · detected on 21/10/2026 00:07 UTC

    Follow the day’s news live. Independent MP’s condition remains critical on Wednesday after surgery to save her remaining leg ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see their politicians be able to go about their business, to be able to get s thei

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see their politicians be able to go about their business, to be able to get s» bd737bd82a15

    After: «Independent MP’s condition remains critical on Wednesday after surgery to save her remaining leg ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see thei» 326d591a0174

  10. Headline · detected on 21/10/2026 00:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: Police are charging ‘almost one individual every week’ Brendan Nugent doesn’t apply for targeting politicians, MP critical after surgery to save second leg bail in first court appearance since alleged attack

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: Police are charging ‘almost one individual every week’ for targeting politicians, MP critical after surgery to save second leg» 2aecd965cf33

    After: «Helen Haines live updates: Brendan Nugent doesn’t apply for bail in first court appearance since alleged attack» f18a224bf282

  11. Headline · detected on 20/10/2026 23:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: Independent Police are charging ‘almost one individual every week’ for targeting politicians, MP critical after surgery to save second leg; alleged attacker to face court leg

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: Independent MP critical after surgery to save second leg; alleged attacker to face court» 331e78604daa

    After: «Helen Haines live updates: Police are charging ‘almost one individual every week’ for targeting politicians, MP critical after surgery to save second leg» 2aecd965cf33

  12. Excerpt · detected on 20/10/2026 22:37 UTC

    Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament There Anthony Albanese has been no change described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to Helen Haines’s condition at the Alfred Hospital in Melbourne . She “remains in a critical condition” the hospital said Wednesday morning. Haines has lost one leg and surgeons operated Tuesday in an effort see their politicians be able to save her other leg. Continue reading... go about their business, to be able to get s

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament There has been no change to Helen Haines’s condition at the Alfred Hospital in Melbourne . She “remains in a critical condition” the hospital said Wednesday morning. Haines has lost one leg and surgeons operated Tuesday in an effort to save her other leg. Continue reading...» 2b12cbeb37e3

    After: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Anthony Albanese has described the police interview on Tuesday with Brendan Nugent as “extensive” but that the motivation of the alleged “violent” attack against Helen Haines is still unknown. Certainly, it’s a reminder that the world is a more dangerous and divided place than it was a generation ago. But I think that Australians do want to see their politicians be able to go about their business, to be able to get s» bd737bd82a15

  13. Headline · detected on 20/10/2026 22:37 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: sister of slain UK Independent MP Jo Cox urges Australians critical after surgery to find ‘common ground’; save second leg; alleged Haines attacker to face court

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: sister of slain UK MP Jo Cox urges Australians to find ‘common ground’; alleged Haines attacker to face court» 1909052b71b8

    After: «Helen Haines live updates: Independent MP critical after surgery to save second leg; alleged attacker to face court» 331e78604daa

  14. Excerpt · detected on 20/10/2026 22:07 UTC

    Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Politicians say more security would ‘let bad people win’ The alleged attack on There has been no change to Helen Haines’s condition at the Alfred Hospital in Melbourne . She “remains in a critical condition” the hospital said Wednesday morning. Haines is something long feared by politicians amid has lost one leg and surgeons operated Tuesday in an increase in hostility towards those in public life, ranging from social media abuse effort to death threats. That was something my sister was brilliant at and I would imagine it’s something Helen is good at. I am devastated for Helen and for save her family, her friends, her colleagues, her other leg. Continue reading...

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Politicians say more security would ‘let bad people win’ The alleged attack on Helen Haines is something long feared by politicians amid an increase in hostility towards those in public life, ranging from social media abuse to death threats. That was something my sister was brilliant at and I would imagine it’s something Helen is good at. I am devastated for Helen and for her family, her friends, her colleagues, her » aa6305b656fb

    After: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament There has been no change to Helen Haines’s condition at the Alfred Hospital in Melbourne . She “remains in a critical condition” the hospital said Wednesday morning. Haines has lost one leg and surgeons operated Tuesday in an effort to save her other leg. Continue reading...» 2b12cbeb37e3

  15. Headline · detected on 20/10/2026 22:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: Sister sister of slain UK MP Jo Cox urges Australians to find ‘common ground’; alleged Haines attacker to face court

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: Sister of slain UK MP Jo Cox urges Australians to find ‘common ground’; alleged Haines attacker to face court» bbbb23bc2e20

    After: «Helen Haines live updates: sister of slain UK MP Jo Cox urges Australians to find ‘common ground’; alleged Haines attacker to face court» 1909052b71b8

  16. Excerpt · detected on 20/10/2026 21:37 UTC

    Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament ‘This is your moment to think about what your politics looks like’, says sister of murdered UK MP Politicians say more security would ‘let bad people win’ The sister of murdered UK MP Jo Cox has said the alleged attack on Australian MP Dr Helen Haines could be a moment is something long feared by politicians amid an increase in hostility towards those in public life, ranging from social media abuse to death threats. That was something my sister was brilliant at and I would imagine it’s something Helen is good at. I am devastated for Australia to “find common ground” Helen and change the way politics is practised in this country. Continue reading... for her family, her friends, her colleagues, her

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament ‘This is your moment to think about what your politics looks like’, says sister of murdered UK MP The sister of murdered UK MP Jo Cox has said the attack on Australian MP Dr Helen Haines could be a moment for Australia to “find common ground” and change the way politics is practised in this country. Continue reading...» f75bf009a92b

    After: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Politicians say more security would ‘let bad people win’ The alleged attack on Helen Haines is something long feared by politicians amid an increase in hostility towards those in public life, ranging from social media abuse to death threats. That was something my sister was brilliant at and I would imagine it’s something Helen is good at. I am devastated for Helen and for her family, her friends, her colleagues, her » aa6305b656fb

  17. Excerpt · detected on 20/10/2026 21:07 UTC

    Follow the day’s news live. Deeply ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Tracee Hutchison will not run in Victoria’s state election in November, despite winning almost a quarter ‘This is your moment to think about what your politics looks like’, says sister of first preferences at murdered UK MP The sister of murdered UK MP Jo Cox has said the by-election in May, citing rising violence towards women. Speaking to AAP, Hutchison shared her distress for attack on Australian MP Dr Helen Haines could be a moment for Australia to “find common ground” and also recalled her personal experience of “a sustained, organised harassment and bullying campaign”. The verbal harassment I experienced, and that change the women my tea way politics is practised in this country. Continue reading...

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Follow the day’s news live. Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Tracee Hutchison will not run in Victoria’s state election in November, despite winning almost a quarter of first preferences at the by-election in May, citing rising violence towards women. Speaking to AAP, Hutchison shared her distress for Helen Haines and also recalled her personal experience of “a sustained, organised harassment and bullying campaign”. The verbal harassment I experienced, and that the women my tea» 87e9a59f679b

    After: «Follow the day’s news live. ‘Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament ‘This is your moment to think about what your politics looks like’, says sister of murdered UK MP The sister of murdered UK MP Jo Cox has said the attack on Australian MP Dr Helen Haines could be a moment for Australia to “find common ground” and change the way politics is practised in this country. Continue reading...» f75bf009a92b

  18. Headline · detected on 20/10/2026 21:07 UTC

    Helen Haines live updates: Alleged Sister of slain UK MP Jo Cox urges Australians to find ‘common ground’; alleged Haines attacker Brendan Nugent to face court in Wangaratta this morning

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Helen Haines live updates: Alleged attacker Brendan Nugent to face court in Wangaratta this morning» ee0a28687528

    After: «Helen Haines live updates: Sister of slain UK MP Jo Cox urges Australians to find ‘common ground’; alleged Haines attacker to face court» bbbb23bc2e20

  19. Excerpt · detected on 20/10/2026 20:25 UTC

    Follow the day’s news live. Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Tracee Hutchison will not run in Victoria’s state election in November, despite winning almost a quarter of first preferences at the by-election in May, citing rising violence towards women. Speaking to AAP, Hutchison shared her distress for Helen Haines’ alleged attacker, Brendan Nugent, has been charged with dangerous driving causing serious injury, intentionally cause serious injury Haines and also recalled her personal experience of “a sustained, organised harassment and bullying campaign”. The verbal harassment I experienced, and that the commonwealth offence of causing harm to a commonwealth public official. He was held overnight to appear at Wangaratta magistrates court this morning at 9.30am, Victoria police confirmed in a statement, adding that it would be alleged the attack was targeted. Continu women my tea

    See versions and fingerprints

    Before: «Follow the day’s news live. Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Helen Haines’ alleged attacker, Brendan Nugent, has been charged with dangerous driving causing serious injury, intentionally cause serious injury and the commonwealth offence of causing harm to a commonwealth public official. He was held overnight to appear at Wangaratta magistrates court this morning at 9.30am, Victoria police confirmed in a statement, adding that it would be alleged the attack was targeted. Continu» e5ec92c4c371

    After: «Follow the day’s news live. Deeply appalled’: politicians condemn alleged attack after Helen Haines critically injured Helen Haines, the principled MP respected across parliament Tracee Hutchison will not run in Victoria’s state election in November, despite winning almost a quarter of first preferences at the by-election in May, citing rising violence towards women. Speaking to AAP, Hutchison shared her distress for Helen Haines and also recalled her personal experience of “a sustained, organised harassment and bullying campaign”. The verbal harassment I experienced, and that the women my tea» 87e9a59f679b

Capture record

Source
https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2026/oct/21/helen-haines-independent-mp-alleged-attack-wangaratta-vigils-court-ntwnfb
Published
20/10/2026 19:46 UTC
Captured
20/10/2026 19:56 UTC
Text fingerprint
2af10c71cbffad72 · 256 words
Changes detected
19
Archived copy
Wayback Machine ↗

The fingerprint (sha256) and the capture date prove what the story said when we analysed it, even if it changes later.

More contrasts in world